• 3,000 firms
  • Independent
  • Trusted
Save up to 70% on staff

News » Financial incentives can backfire, new research reveals

Financial incentives can backfire, new research reveals

Photo from Getty Images

MASSACHUSETTS, UNITED STATES — Recent studies have shown that monetary bonuses, long considered a reliable tool for motivating employees, can actually have the opposite effect. 

Two large-scale experiments conducted by Harvard Business Review in retail settings have uncovered unexpected consequences of financial incentives, challenging conventional wisdom about employee motivation.

Attendance bonus increases absenteeism

Researchers in a German retail chain implemented an attendance bonus for apprentices across 232 stores. Contrary to expectations, the monetary incentive led to a significant increase in absence days. The study revealed that employees who received the bonus began to view attendance differently.

“Many participants reported feeling a significantly weaker feeling of obligation to come to work when not sick and that they felt less guilty about staying at home. The bonus had apparently signaled to the employees that perfect attendance was not considered “normal” and expected,” the researchers noted

Profit-sharing bonus undermines performance reviews

Another experiment involving 224 stores in a discount retail chain yielded equally surprising results. While bi-weekly performance review meetings with district managers increased profits by more than 7%, the addition of a profit-sharing bonus for store managers negated this positive effect entirely.

The researchers found that “the monetary bonus wiped out the sizeable value of the review conversations entirely.” The bonus appeared to change the nature of these conversations, leading to increased self-reliance among store managers and less candid discussions about problems.

Understanding the psychology behind incentives

These findings highlight the complex relationship between financial rewards and employee behavior. 

Jean Tirole and Roland Bénabou’s work on reputational motivation offers insight into this phenomenon. They suggest that “financial rewards can undermine the reputational motivation for performing an activity, as they can ‘create doubt about the true motive’ for which an action is taken.”

The studies underscore the importance of considering incentives’ signaling effects. As the researchers point out, “Incentives wield significant influence over organizational dynamics, yet their efficacy is contingent upon many contextual factors.”

Moving forward, managers are advised to evaluate potential incentive programs carefully, considering not only their direct effects but also the unintended messages they may convey. 

Start your
journey today

  • Independent
  • Free
  • Transparent

About OA

Outsource Accelerator is the trusted source of independent information, advisory and expert implementation of Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)

The #1 outsourcing authority

Outsource Accelerator offers the world’s leading aggregator marketplace for outsourcing. It specifically provides the conduit between Philippines outsourcing suppliers and the businesses – clients – across the globe.

The Outsource Accelerator website has over 5,000 articles, 450+ podcast episodes, and a comprehensive directory with 4000+ BPO companies… all designed to make it easier for clients to learn about – and engage with – outsourcing.

About Derek Gallimore

Derek Gallimore has been in business for 20 years, outsourcing for over eight years, and has been living in Manila (the heart of global outsourcing) since 2014. Derek is the founder and CEO of Outsource Accelerator, and is regarded as a leading expert on all things outsourcing.

“Excellent service for outsourcing advice and expertise for my business.”

Learn more
Banner Image
Get 3 Free Quotes Verified Outsourcing Suppliers
3,000 firms.Just 2 minutes to complete.
SAVE UP TO
70% ON STAFF COSTS
Learn more

Connect with over 3,000 outsourcing services providers.

Banner Image

Transform your business with skilled offshore talent.

  • 3,000 firms
  • Simple
  • Transparent
Banner Image